Verdict: For new and low-volume stores, the cheapest way to accept card payments online is Stripe at 2.9% + $0.30 with no monthly fee, the strongest default among flat-rate processors. Once monthly processing volume reliably exceeds $8,000 to $10,000, Helcim’s interchange-plus model takes over as the lowest-cost option, with automatic volume discounts requiring no negotiation. ACH bank transfers via Dwolla or Stripe are dramatically cheaper than card payments for high-AOV B2B or recurring billing scenarios.
The cheapest way to accept payments online is not a single answer. It depends on three variables: how much a store processes each month, what its average order value is, and whether its customers are consumers or businesses. Payment processing costs have three layers: the transaction rate, any monthly or gateway fees, and surcharges for international cards or currency conversion. A processor that looks cheap at $500 per month in volume can easily be beaten by a different model once volume climbs past a recognizable threshold.
Low-Volume Stores and the Cheapest Way to Process Payments
For stores under $5,000 per month, the cheapest starting point is a flat-rate processor with no monthly fee. Any fixed monthly cost at that volume takes too long to pay off in savings.
Stripe and Square both charge 2.9% + $0.30 per online transaction with no monthly fee, making them the two lowest-cost flat-rate options at the entry tier. A WooCommerce store paired with Stripe is a particularly lean setup: WooCommerce core is free, so the only recurring cost is Stripe’s transaction rate. Shopify’s cheapest plan adds $39 per month in platform overhead before a single transaction fee is charged, which shifts the math against it at very low volume.
Payment Depot‘s $79 per month membership only breaks even against flat-rate processing at roughly $10,000 per month in volume, per the company’s published pricing. Below that threshold, flat-rate processors with no monthly commitment are the right starting point, and Stripe or Square are the two most cost-competitive options available without any lock-in.
No Monthly Fee: Which Flat-Rate Processor Charges the Least
Among no-monthly-fee flat-rate processors, Braintree has the lowest percentage at 2.59% + $0.49, though Stripe’s 2.9% + $0.30 is cheaper on orders under about $150 where the fixed component carries more weight.
Buyer Persona: The founder running a direct-to-consumer brand on WooCommerce or a custom cart who processes between $2,000 and $8,000 per month and wants the lowest-cost flat-rate processor with no monthly commitment. The table below compares Stripe, Braintree, Square, and PayPal Standard on per-transaction cost across realistic order values. The interchange-plus vs. flat-rate threshold decision is mapped in the section that follows.
Four processors dominate this tier: Stripe, Square, PayPal Standard, and Braintree. Stripe charges 2.9% + $0.30. Square matches that at 2.9% + $0.30, designed more around omnichannel retail than pure ecommerce. Braintree (owned by PayPal) charges 2.59% + $0.49, which is cheaper on higher-AOV orders where the percentage component matters more than the fixed cent. PayPal Standard checkout charges 3.49% + $0.49, the most expensive default of the four and a notable outlier given the brand’s dominance in consumer checkout familiarity.
On a $100 transaction, PayPal Standard costs roughly $3.98 versus Stripe’s $3.20. That $0.78 difference multiplies across thousands of transactions per month. For stores that want PayPal’s buyer trust signal without paying its standard rate, connecting Braintree achieves lower processing cost through the same PayPal corporate infrastructure.
| Processor | Online Transaction Rate | Monthly Fee | Pricing Model | Best Fit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stripe | 2.9% + $0.30 | None | Flat-rate | New stores, developers, WooCommerce |
| Square | 2.9% + $0.30 | None | Flat-rate | Omnichannel retail with POS |
| Braintree | 2.59% + $0.49 | None | Flat-rate | High-AOV stores wanting PayPal branding |
| PayPal Standard | 3.49% + $0.49 | None | Flat-rate | Marketplaces needing buyer trust signal |
| Helcim | Interchange + 0.3% + $0.08 | None | Interchange-plus | Growing stores from $5k per month |
| Stax | Interchange + $0.08 | $99 | Interchange-plus | High-volume stores above $20k per month |
| Payment Depot | Interchange (membership) | $79 | Membership interchange | Stores consistently above $10k per month |
| Shopify Payments | 2.9% + $0.30 (Basic plan) | Shopify plan required | Flat-rate | Any merchant already on a Shopify plan |
| 2Checkout (Verifone) | 3.5% + $0.35 | None | Flat-rate | Cross-border digital goods, broad multi-currency support |
| Adyen | Interchange++ (~$0.11-$0.22 per txn) | Minimum monthly billing | Interchange++ | Enterprise stores above $1M per year |
| Dwolla | 0.5%, capped at $5 | From $250 (API plans) | ACH only | Recurring B2B billing, large invoices |
Verify current rates directly at Stripe’s pricing page, PayPal’s merchant fee schedule, and Helcim’s pricing page before making any commitment, as rates are updated periodically.
Stripe vs PayPal: What the Rate Gap Actually Costs Per Transaction
Stripe is cheaper than PayPal Standard on every order size, and the cost gap compounds into real money at any meaningful monthly volume.
On a $50 order, Stripe costs $1.75 and PayPal Standard costs $2.24. On a $200 order, Stripe costs $6.10 and PayPal Standard costs $7.47. For a store processing $20,000 per month in $100 average orders, that difference accumulates to hundreds of dollars monthly in avoidable cost.
PayPal retains one real advantage: checkout conversion. Many online shoppers have saved PayPal credentials and trust the brand enough to complete purchases they’d abandon when asked to enter card details manually. Stores selling to general consumers sometimes see a measurable lift in completed checkouts when a PayPal button sits alongside standard card fields. The trade-off is a higher per-transaction rate in exchange for fewer abandoned carts from buyers who prefer PayPal’s wallet.
Braintree, PayPal’s developer-focused gateway, is the middle path: it uses PayPal’s infrastructure, can display PayPal buttons at checkout, and processes card payments at 2.59% + $0.49.
When Interchange-Plus Pricing Is the Cheapest Way to Scale
Interchange-plus beats flat-rate once a store reliably processes $8,000 to $10,000 per month. At that level, paying actual network rates plus a small markup saves more than any blended flat-rate average.
With interchange-plus, the merchant pays the actual network interchange rate set by Visa and Mastercard plus a small processor markup. That’s cheaper than flat-rate at meaningful volume because the merchant benefits when lower-cost cards, such as basic debit, are used at checkout, rather than subsidizing a blended average that absorbs expensive premium rewards card costs.
Helcim charges interchange + 0.3% + $0.08 for online transactions with no monthly fee. Its automatic volume discounts apply at $25,000, $50,000, and $100,000 per month in processing volume, with no negotiation required. This makes Helcim the most practical interchange-plus entry point for scaling merchants. Stax charges interchange + $0.08 per transaction with a $99 per month subscription, absorbing that overhead at high volume. Payment Depot‘s $79 per month membership passes interchange at cost, with the break-even point against flat-rate falling at roughly $10,000 per month. Adyen offers interchange++ pricing with a per-transaction markup of approximately $0.11 to $0.22, but its minimum monthly billing requirements make it suited only to enterprise merchants processing above $1 million per year.
Debit-heavy stores save more because debit interchange rates are often half of premium credit card rates. A processor quoting a compelling markup is only part of the cost picture. Any store reliably processing above $8,000 to $10,000 per month should run a comparison using its own average order value and card mix before defaulting to flat-rate.
Pro tip from Ronen Abudi, e-commerce and GEO specialist (ronenabudi.com): Before switching to an interchange-plus provider, request a sample statement using your actual card mix. Knowing what percentage of your orders come from debit cards versus premium travel rewards cards determines how much you will actually save over flat-rate pricing.
Shopify Payments vs a Third-Party Processor on Shopify
Using a third-party processor on Shopify costs more than the rate card suggests, because Shopify stacks a surcharge on top of whatever the external processor charges. On the Basic plan at $39 per month, that surcharge is 2%. On the Shopify plan at $105 per month, it drops to 1%. On the Advanced plan at $399 per month, it falls to 0.5%.
For a Shopify merchant using Stripe on the Basic plan, the combined cost reaches an effective 4.9% + $0.30 per transaction. Switching to Shopify Payments eliminates that surcharge entirely. At the Basic plan level, Shopify Payments charges 2.9% + $0.30 with no additional penalty. This makes Shopify Payments the right call for any merchant already committed to a Shopify plan, assuming they qualify by country and have no need for Stripe’s deeper API functionality.
Merchants not on Shopify avoid this question entirely. A WooCommerce store using Stripe pays only 2.9% + $0.30 with no platform penalty, which is functionally cheaper than Shopify’s Basic plan when WooCommerce itself costs nothing. The $39 per month Shopify plan overhead must be justified by Shopify’s other features, not by payment processing cost alone.
ACH Transfers: Often the Cheapest Way to Handle High-Value Orders
ACH bank transfer processing costs roughly 0.5% to 1.5% per transaction, capped at $5 to $10 depending on the provider. That’s two to four times cheaper than card processing at equivalent dollar amounts.
Dwolla is the specialist ACH provider in this comparison, charging 0.5% capped at $5 per transfer on its Pay-as-you-Go tier. For a $1,000 B2B invoice, that works out to $5 in processing cost. Card processing the same invoice through Stripe costs $29.30 at the standard rate. For recurring wholesale orders or large B2B invoices, that cost difference justifies the added onboarding step of collecting and verifying customer bank account details before the first payment.
Stripe also supports ACH debit natively at approximately 0.8% per transaction capped at $5, making it a practical single-processor option for merchants who want both card and bank transfer without managing a separate gateway. Settlement is the main trade-off: ACH bank transfers take one to three business days to clear versus next-day card settlement. That delay rules out ACH for standard consumer checkout but suits B2B invoice payments, subscription billing, and any high-AOV scenario where the buyer expects scheduled rather than instant settlement.
Quick Takeaways
- Stripe and Square share the lowest flat-rate online fee at 2.9% + $0.30 with no monthly cost, making either the default cheapest way for stores under $5,000 per month in volume.
- PayPal Standard at 3.49% + $0.49 costs significantly more per transaction than Stripe; Braintree at 2.59% + $0.49 is a cheaper PayPal-infrastructure alternative for high-AOV orders.
- Helcim’s interchange-plus model with no monthly fee and automatic volume discounts at $25k, $50k, and $100k monthly thresholds is the most cost-efficient option for stores scaling past $8,000 to $10,000 per month.
- Shopify merchants on any paid plan should use Shopify Payments to avoid the 0.5% to 2% third-party surcharge; WooCommerce plus Stripe avoids this penalty entirely since there is no platform fee.
- ACH bank transfers via Dwolla or Stripe cost 0.5% to 1.5%, capped at $5 to $10, and are two to four times cheaper than card payments for high-AOV B2B or subscription billing scenarios.
- 2Checkout supports a broad range of currencies for international digital goods sales but carries the highest base flat rate of the processors compared here, at 3.5% + $0.35.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Which no-monthly-fee processor has the lowest flat-rate for online card payments?
- Stripe and Square both charge 2.9% + $0.30 per online transaction with no monthly fee, putting them at the same lowest flat-rate tier among major processors. Braintree edges below at 2.59% + $0.49, but only saves money when average order values consistently exceed roughly $150, where the lower percentage outweighs the higher fixed component.
- Is Stripe genuinely cheaper than PayPal for processing online payments?
- Yes, by a consistent margin at every order size. PayPal Standard charges 3.49% + $0.49 versus Stripe’s 2.9% + $0.30, translating to roughly $0.78 more per $100 order. Merchants who want PayPal’s brand recognition without the premium rate can connect Braintree, which runs on PayPal infrastructure at 2.59% + $0.49 per transaction.
- At what monthly volume does interchange-plus pricing become worthwhile?
- Most practitioners put the crossover point between $8,000 and $10,000 per month in card processing volume. Below that level, any monthly subscription fee that accompanies interchange-plus processors typically cancels out the per-transaction savings. Helcim, which charges interchange-plus with no monthly fee, shifts that break-even lower for stores that want to transition before hitting $10,000 per month.
- How much does Shopify Payments save over using a third-party processor on Shopify?
- On Shopify’s Basic plan, switching to Shopify Payments eliminates a 2% surcharge applied to every transaction processed through an external provider. A store processing $10,000 per month on the Basic plan saves $200 monthly by moving to Shopify Payments. On higher Shopify tiers the surcharge drops to 1% or 0.5%, reducing but not eliminating the savings from switching.
- Are ACH bank transfers significantly cheaper than credit card processing for ecommerce?
- For high-AOV transactions, ACH is two to four times cheaper than card processing. Dwolla charges 0.5% capped at $5 per transfer, meaning a $500 B2B payment costs $2.50 via ACH versus roughly $14.80 at Stripe’s card rate. The trade-off is settlement time: ACH typically takes one to three business days, so it suits subscription billing and wholesale orders more than standard consumer checkout.
- Does Helcim genuinely have lower fees than Stripe for a small ecommerce business?
- At low volume, the difference is modest. Helcim’s interchange-plus model saves most when processing volumes are higher and when a store’s card mix skews toward lower-interchange debit cards. At volumes above $10,000 per month, Helcim’s rate structure typically beats Stripe’s flat rate by a meaningful margin. Below $5,000 per month, Stripe’s simplicity and predictability often make it the more practical starting point before the savings justify a switch.
